
The Corporate Treasury Playbook Part III
Welcome, welcome, welcome to The Secret CFO’s Playbook. Your Saturday safe space for a finance nerd-out.
CFOs are all over the news this week. Nvidia CFO Colette Kress is now also interim CEO, taking over from [some other dude]. Oh, to be a fly on the wall in that boardroom right now. I can’t wait for the Netflix movie. Meanwhile, Anthropic CFO Krishna Rao has been on his IPO glory tour.
But… hey, it’s not all glitz and glamour. We still have a job to do. And this week, that job is Part III of the CFO’s Guide to Corporate Treasury:
In Week 1, we defined Treasury, why it exists, and what it looks like when it goes wrong.
Last week, we got into risk management and how to keep your Treasury function from falling asleep at the wheel or, worse… deciding it’s a baby hedge fund.
This week, we get into the practical choices. What do you do when interest rates, exchange rates, or commodity prices can make a mess of your plan?
Anyways … before we get into that, I want to tell you about Airwallex, who know their Treasury onions. (Mmm… delicious Treasury onions.)
Cash collected before you deliver is my favorite source of working capital. Use it well, and it’s growth rocket fuel.
But it’s not all gravy, it comes with a promise to deliver in the future.
And that can get complicated, especially for industries like travel. Deposits land nine months early, suppliers get paid in different currencies, and FX moves the entire time. As Tripsite’s CEO puts it: float is how companies grow fast… and how they go bust faster.
Airwallex asked four US travel industry finance leaders how they use float without crashing.
Now Boarding: Your Margin Call
As corporate finance jobs go… working in corporate Treasury at a major airline is high-stakes stuff.
On the balls-of-steel-ometer (it’s a thing), it’s 10 out of 10.

Training for a role in an airline Treasury team
Just ask the Treasury team at Southwest Airlines during the GFC.
In 2008, our tree-mashing villains from last week’s post made a currency bet big enough to swallow the business.
Well… Southwest was doing billion-dollar deals with Wall Street, too, around the same time. But in their case, a risk that size came with the day job. Treasury earned top billing.
You sell a ticket today at an agreed price, but buy fuel to fly the plane on the departure date, no matter how much it costs.
And in 2008, that got bloody expensive.
Crude oil soared from about $90 a barrel at the start of the year to nearly $150 in July. Fuel and oil spend was equal to roughly a third of Southwest’s revenue. Their net margin that year was just 1.6%.
Quick math says an unhedged 5% move in that one expense line would wipe out the entirety of their net income. If you ever wondered why running an airline is so tough, there’s your answer…
So how do you hedge jet fuel?
It’s not easy. Jet fuel wasn’t (and still isn’t) traded on an organized futures exchange. Southwest used derivatives on crude oil, heating oil, and unleaded gasoline as a sort of proxy recipe. Getting that lot to track the fuel bill on the seats you’re selling? That’s a tricky math puzzle to solve, even before everyone agrees on how many seats you’ll sell, their price, and how much fuel you’ll need.
Entering 2008, Southwest had more than 70% of its expected fuel needs protected at about $51 a barrel on a crude-oil-equivalent basis. (Call back: Remember oil was at $150 that July.)
Southwest reported $1.3 billion in cash settlement gains on its fuel hedges that year, which helped offset the higher cost of jet fuel. For scale, that’s nearly three times its reported operating profit and over 10% of revenue. Gargantuan stuff.
But that isn’t even the cleverest part.
At the end of September 2008, Southwest held $2.5 billion in cash collateral from its hedge counterparties… just to show how ‘in the money’ those hedges were. Then oil collapsed to ~$35 a barrel in December. And by Christmas, Southwest was itself having to post collateral, and $230 million of it…on demand.
And in case it wasn’t obvious, for Southwest, collateral meant cash.
That $230 million collateral call would have been more than $800 million, by Southwest’s estimate, without some smart maneuvering. The team sold zero-cost collars and fixed-price swaps, cutting its net hedge coverage to about 10% of expected fuel consumption in each year from 2009 through 2013. This released cash to help foot the monster collateral bill.
They also struck a deal with one counterparty to pledge 20 Boeing 737s in place of cash if the collateral requirement fell within a specified range.
By December, Southwest took on some risk of another oil spike to hold on to more cash. That’s a hell of a call to make in the middle of a financial crisis.
Usually I’d say Treasury doesn’t belong in the front office. In this case, they earned a spot in the damn cockpit.
Three Men and a Basis Point
Treasury manages plenty of risks, and market risks are often the trickiest. For most Treasury teams, there’s a sort of holy triumvirate of market risks that can balls up an otherwise perfectly good operating plan.
Interest rates. What happens to your cash flow when the interest rate moves up (or down)?
Foreign exchange. What happens to your margin when you sell in one currency and pay your suppliers in another?
Commodities. What happens when the stuff you buy gets more expensive before you can put your prices up?
Let’s take them one at a time.
An Unhealthy Interest
I’ve seen CFOs take out the wrong kind of debt simply because they’d already decided on either a fixed or floating rate.
It’s a trade-off we understand intuitively. We deal with it in our personal finances… and there’s no smile smugger than the one on the face of someone who locked in a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage in 2021.
In corporate finance, though, different debt products tend to come with different rate structures. Start with “I want a fixed/floating rate” and you’ve already narrowed the pool of financing you’ll consider.

These products all come with their own economics, lender types, security requirements, covenants, and reporting. Some give you a committed line you can draw any time. Others put the cash on your balance sheet on day one. So keep both columns open while you work out what financing the business actually needs.
You’ll have a mix of fixed and floating debt once you layer those products together. The question is how much that mix matters. How much floating-rate debt have you actually drawn? What would a rate move do to your interest bill? And how big is that bill relative to what the business earns? Gross leverage and interest cover give you a sense of how much room you have.
And that’s just the debt side of the ledger…
If you’re sitting on a pile of cash that earns a floating rate, some of that extra interest expense might come back to you as interest income. But if the cash is in a fixed-term deposit, its rate won’t change until it matures and you reinvest it.
So look at the debt and cash you have today, then roll both forward with a forecast. As you draw or repay debt, roll deposits, and spend cash, your exposure can change quite a bit.
Let’s look at how that could play out with an example:

Two things are going on in that table. First, the business is borrowing more, so the interest bill increases. Second, the debt mix goes from 80% fixed today to 80% floating by Year 3. Put those together and a one-point rise in SOFR goes from costing you $10,000 a year to $900,000.
Every time old debt rolls off and you replace it, you get another chance to decide how much of the interest bill you want to fix. And your answer can change depending on how far out you’re looking. You might want certainty for the next year while that new production line launches, and be happier leaving more floating further out. You have more time to react, and locking in the price for longer might cost you more than it’s worth.
And remember, fixed is a position too. If rates fall and your highly levered competitor is 100% floating, their interest bill comes down while yours stays put. And suddenly they’ve got a cheaper war chest. They’ve got more cash to cut prices, hire salespeople, or make an acquisition. You bought certainty, but it comes at a huge price.
Then there’s the bit I see most businesses miss: there might be a natural hedge hiding in your own P&L.
Say rates are rising… basic economics say it probably suggests something about inflation. So, in an inflating economy what’s happening to the business at the same time? Can you put prices up and hold on to your volumes? How quickly do your wages and input costs rise? If you can get pricing through faster than costs go up, the extra operating cash might help cover a bigger interest bill.
So before you decide how much to fix, stress-test the interest bill and the operating plan in the same scenario. That’ll tell you how much floating-rate risk the business can live with, and for how long.
Interest rate swaps let you dial your floating-rate exposure up or down without changing the underlying debt. As a rule of thumb, they start to make economic sense when you’re looking to swap $10m to $20m of debt. At $50m or more, the case for getting a quote is compelling.
The FX-Files
Last week, we talked about how FX decisions are spread across the business. That makes it a much messier job than managing interest rates. The first challenge is working out what you’re actually exposed to. And even if you can drag every last bit of information out of the business and get the position exactly right on Monday… it can still be wrong by Friday.
Maybe procurement switches a component supplier, and a bill you expected to pay in euros is now in dollars. Meanwhile, Sales shifts more volume into a market where customers pay in euros. And if the volumes you hedged never show up, you can end up with more currency under contract than the business needs.
All of that is moving on both sides of the ledger. The gap you planned to hedge in the budget can look wildly different by the time the bills are due.
Let’s look at an example.
Ignore the tariff minefield for a minute and imagine you’re a US pump manufacturer that buys and sells in Europe.
In your budget, you expect to pay out €1m to €3m more (in euros) than you’re taking in each month. So Treasury books six monthly forwards to buy the euros it expects to need at $1.10 per euro. If the euro gets more expensive, your dollar cost is locked in.
Job done?
Well… two things happen.
First, the euro falls. By June, it’s down to $1.00. You’ve agreed to pay $1.10, so you miss out on the cheaper euros. But not a big deal; that’s a trade-off you signed up for when you fixed the rate.
The second thing is more awkward. A European distributor brings orders forward, boosting euro receipts. Then a European supplier misses a delivery, and Procurement moves orders to a US supplier that bills in dollars.
You no longer need to buy Euros, you need to sell:

In Q2, you’d planned to buy €8m. The business actually had €4.5m to sell. But the forwards you booked in January still delivered €8m, so Treasury had to turn around and sell €12.5m at spot.
Across the six months, those original hedges left you $655k worse off than if you’d converted the cash flows you actually had at spot. The exposure you thought you’d hedged came back to bite you in the ass.
Or… in a parallel universe, your Treasury team is on the ball and sees this coming.
Before the April settlement, they get wind of the supplier switch and rerun the cash forecast. They now expect to have €12.5m to sell over Q2, including the €8m the original forwards will deliver. They lock in those sales at $1.07 per euro, before the euro falls further. The six-month hit comes down from $655k to $55k.
In short… a lot rides on what Treasury knew, and when it knew it.
And if you trade internationally, even if you invoice and pay in your own currency, you think you don’t have this kind of stuff buried all over your P&L? I’ll bet you do. Your supplier can put its dollar price up because its costs are in euros. Your European customers can buy less because your dollar price just got more expensive for them.
The hard bit is getting to the bottom of what you’re actually exposed to, when it’ll hit, and how much you trust the forecast. That takes good reporting, a cash forecast you can rely on, and people in Sales and Procurement who know how to tell Treasury when something changes.
Once you’ve got that, there’s a whole menu of FX products to shop from:
Forwards. Lock in a rate for a set amount on a set date. Straightforward when you know what you’ll need. If the order disappears, you still have a deal with the bank.
Options. Pay a premium for the right to exchange at an agreed rate. You can walk away if the cash flow doesn’t happen or the market gives you a better rate.
Collars. Put a floor and a ceiling around the rate you’ll get. You can reduce the premium by giving up some of the benefit if the currency moves your way.
You can get pretty sophisticated here. I’ve always preferred to keep it simple, sticking to my ‘flipchart’ test from last week.
A Commodity of Errors
So… to the final part of our holy trinity. I’ve saved the trickiest for last. Commodities.
All the same FX problems apply. The forecast can be wrong, volumes can move, the business can change its mind, and the market can surprise you. If you trade the stuff, you can even go from a net seller to a net buyer or vice versa.
Now imagine you’re a drinks company buying finished cans. When the price of aluminum moves, your margin moves with it.
Here’s what makes that so tricky to manage:
The exposure is buried in what you buy. There’s no line called “aluminum” in your P&L. It’s in the cost of the can, along with the cost of making it and getting it to your factory. Your supplier might not even be straight with you on the true mix of the cost.
Procurement is already making decisions about the risk. Your can buyer will think aluminum is their job, and they’re probably right. They know how the supplier prices it, what they can lock in, and whether the business could switch to a different pack altogether.
Sometimes the hedge is in the contract. Your can supplier might fix the aluminum component for six months. Or your customer might agree to a surcharge that moves with the same aluminum index you’re paying against.
A market hedge might track a different price. Treasury can get a quote on an aluminum benchmark and pay a spread to trade it. Good luck finding a hedge that moves in lockstep with the price of a finished can. And maybe you don’t have access to the same full suite of hedging products as you would with FX.
Usage can change even when sales don’t. A production line goes down for two weeks. You cancel the can order and now you’ve got a hedge to sort out as well. Or Sales shifts more volume into bottles. You can hit your sales budget and still use a wildly different amount of aluminum.
Your customers want protection too. If they ask you to hold their price for six months, they’ve got their own budget to worry about and don’t fancy betting it on your buying skills.
It’s what makes the Southwest example we started with so impressive. Gargantuan positions in an insanely volatile market…
So, how do you make this real for you? Doing this well is deeply business-specific, but here are some questions you can ask yourself:

Net-net
Placing a hedge is the easy bit… a mere phone call. The proper work is making sure they hear about the supplier switch, the late payment, or the delayed expansion while there’s still time.
Next week, we’ll get into how that relationship works for cash. How do you keep it visible, available, and moving safely when things get hairy?


What did you think of this week’s edition?

Announcements
The recording of my Playbook Live session and responses to the Q&A will be released tomorrow. If you registered, you will be sent a link tomorrow with the details
If you enjoyed today’s content, don’t forget to subscribe.
🥓🔥 Stay Crispy,

Disclaimer: I am not your accountant, tax advisor, lawyer, CFO, director, or friend. Well, maybe I’m your friend, but I am not any of those other things. Everything I publish represents my opinions only, not advice. Running the finances for a company is serious business, and you should take the proper advice you need.




