

‘AI skills’ are fast becoming the new ‘proficient in Microsoft Office’ on a résumé.
OK, dude, everyone says that…but what have you actually built?
Numeric’s Finance Engineer Cup is back for round two…an AI building tournament for accounting and finance pros. Register and get access to the challenge straight away: a billing scenario for a fictional company. Make the finals and demo your own build live on December 17. Winner takes $5,000.
Round 1 closes on November 29. You can compete yourself, or forward it to your team.

👉🏼 Tough situation got you spinning in circles? Send me your questions, and you might just see yourself in next week’s Mailbag. Submit anonymously using the button below:
In this week’s Mailbag, it’s a Maintainable Free Cashflow (MFCF) Special!! On Thursday, I hosted a live workshop where we got into the weeds of MFCF, it was a lot of fun.
So, we are celebrating today by sharing some of the questions I got during that session. If you need an MFCF refresher, you can brush up here.
Here’s what’s up this week:
Is the development spend for GTA VI maintenance or growth CapEx?
Right sizing cash reserves
Growing factoring debt safely with revenue

Agata from Poland
Is creating the new GTA VI game a maintenance CapEx or a growth CapEx for the game development company?

Oooo, what a super fun question, Agata.
This caught me off guard in the live session, but I've been thinking about it in the few days since. So let me give you my reflections.

It's an interesting question for video games in general. But I'd argue GTA VI is a unique case even within the gaming industry.
Given that game development cycles can run for many years, there's a genuine GAAP question about what development expenditure can be capitalized versus expensed as incurred.
That's important from a financial reporting perspective, but quite boring to me. As you know, I'm much more interested in the underlying economics than the balance sheet treatment.
At the end of the day, we're talking about a series of cash flows. And the real question is how much of that investment is required to maintain the existing earnings power of the business, versus how much is genuinely creating new earnings potential.
Let's start with games that have annual releases as a simple example. Think Call of Duty, or EA's FC soccer series (previously FIFA) which I've been playing on and off for three decades. (Don't grow up… it's a trap.)
These franchises have relatively short annual release cycles. The next edition replaces the previous one as the primary driver of new game sales, even if older titles continue generating some revenue.
It’s pretty clear, in this case, that a significant proportion of this development expenditure is firmly in the maintenance category. If EA suddenly skipped a year of its flagship sports releases, it could do real damage to a predictable earnings pattern.
And this principle applies beyond annual franchises.
Even if you're a developer producing entirely different games, you're still under pressure to maintain a pipeline of releases. Overlapping development cycles are what ultimately create a sustainable stream of earnings. In that sense, some of the investment in producing new games is economically necessary just to stand still.
But GTA VI is a different beast altogether.
Consider a few things:
It's arriving 13 years after GTA V, following an extraordinarily long development cycle.
Outside estimates suggest that development spend may be roughly $1bn to $2bn. Massive.
GTA V, released in 2013, is still generating meaningful revenue today, particularly through GTA Online. So a much longer life cycle.
Some industry forecasts have projected $3bn to $5bn in global sales during its first week alone.
It's Rockstar's first major new title since Red Dead Redemption 2 in 2018.
Let's be clear. This isn't just a video game. It's not just a big video game. It's not even just potentially the biggest video game launch of all time.
It's very likely going to be the biggest individual launch in the history of media.
And I think that fundamentally changes how we should think about the investment.
The development cycle, enormous upfront capital commitment, and potentially decade-long revenue tail look much more like an infrastructure investment than the regular expenditure required to maintain a conventional product portfolio.
You have a huge upfront cash outflow, a launch event that could generate extraordinary returns, and then a long period of ongoing monetization.
Of course, some of that investment is replacing the earnings power of GTA V. Some could create entirely new earnings streams. And some is effectively building the platform on which the franchise will operate for another decade.
So my answer is that I wouldn't classify GTA VI neatly as either maintenance or growth capex.
I'd treat it as a major standalone capital allocation decision, with its own capital structure and even funding. Like a whole damn industry (or infrastructure project) in its own right.
Another way of thinking about it though is if Rockstar must keep investing billions every decade or so to sustain the GTA franchise, isn't some of that expenditure maintenance investment, just on a very long cycle?
Trying to force something this unusual into a binary maintenance versus growth framework probably tells you less about its economics than analyzing the investment on its own merits.
What a lovely question!
And yes, I already have GTA VI preloaded and ready to go for this weekend. Some things are more important than free cash flow analysis.
TLDR: GTA VI is more than a growth vs maintenance CapEx decision. It’s a whole damn industry.

Virginia from the US
Free cashflow is nice. How about cash reserves in relation to MFCF? How much should a company keep in cash reserves?

Thanks, Virginia. You're right. Free cash flow is nice. Maintainable free cash flow is even nicer.
I'm going to try to avoid the boring "it depends" answer.
I've seen people suggest keeping 3–6 months of fixed operating expenses in cash reserves. It's not a terrible rule of thumb, but it's far too simplistic to be a one-size-fits-all answer.
Let's go back to first principles.
Keeping the business liquid is one of your primary duties as CFO. Which means managing the risk of running out of money to as close to zero as practically possible. But doing so in the most capital-efficient way.
So let's look at the variables that should determine your minimum cash reserves.
Available credit facilities: You can be much more aggressive with minimum cash holdings if you have somewhere reliable to go when things get ugly. An overdraft, committed credit facility, or supportive shareholder. But that backstop needs to be genuinely available. Too many businesses discover that their credit facilities become unusable precisely when they need them, thanks to embedded covenants or other restrictions.
Revenue quality: How confident are you in tomorrow's revenue? A subscription business with low churn and predictable collections can operate with a smaller cushion than one that's out scrapping for every last dollar of revenue every day. It's about the volatility and predictability of future cash generation.
Working capital intensity: If growth requires you to fund inventory, receivables, or other working capital ahead of collecting cash, you need the liquidity to finance that growth. And remember, even a highly profitable, fast-growing business can run out of cash.
Seasonality: Annual seasonality is super important. Predictable peaks and troughs in cash flow mean you need to hold enough liquidity to fund the business through those periods, even if the full-year cash position looks healthy.
Intramonth volatility: People often forget this one. A retailer collecting cash daily is very different from a B2B business paying wages and suppliers throughout the month while customers settle at month-end. Both might have healthy month-end cash balances, but very different liquidity needs.
Operating leverage: If revenue falls, how quickly can you shut off costs? In some low-margin businesses, a large proportion of costs are variable and fall automatically with sales. In others, particularly businesses with large fixed cost bases, revenue can disappear long before expenses do.
So, that's a long way of saying that what you really need is a good quality cash forecast.
For a reasonably mature business, I like to think about what I call my 18 & 95 rule.
Essentially, size the liquidity cushion to survive a reasonable downside scenario over the next 18 months, with a target of around 95% confidence that the business won't run out of available liquidity. I wrote more about this here.
That requires a good base-case forecast, a credible downside case, and a proper understanding of what management could actually do if things deteriorated.
And don't forget debt repayments, covenant constraints, and the timing of cash flows.
The 95% isn't some magical statistical precision. It's a way of expressing the level of risk you're prepared to tolerate… I’ve always found it a good planning assumption over an 18 month horizon. It gives you enough runway to deal with the 1 in 20 time you hit the tail risk.
Growth businesses are different. There, I'd be much more focused on the funding environment, your ability to raise capital, and how lean you could run the business if that funding wasn't available.
There's another exercise I like, which I call the Armageddon survival buffer.
Imagine all your sales stopped tomorrow. You immediately took every evasive action available to preserve cash.
How long could the business survive? That answer might be measured in months, weeks, or even days. Then ask yourself how sick that number makes you feel.
It's not a particularly scientific approach, but I can tell you it's a useful way of focusing the mind! And one that became real for many businesses at the start of the pandemic in 2020.
TLDR: Don't size cash reserves using a generic rule of thumb. Forecast your downside liquidity needs, test your survival buffer, and manage the risk.

Floris from The Netherlands
We’re a growing B2B food wholesaler with a seasonal stock build, funded mainly by a factoring facility that lends against receivables and stock. Because we grow, the draw keeps growing too, so our debt position rises every year.
We’re defining our MFCF and have two questions: Should MFCF include the full working capital movement or only what it takes to run at today’s level? But if we keep running at today's level the draw decreases in the long run. What is growth is hard to define, how should we do that?

Wonderful question. And an extremely important one.
It also ties nicely into my recent Boardroom Brief on the risks of receivables financing.
Many of these arrangements are specifically structured to avoid having the financing presented as debt on the balance sheet, by qualifying as a sale of receivables rather than a borrowing.
The terms and structures of receivables financing agreements have evolved faster than GAAP. Mind you, fossils move faster than GAAP.
Imagine you have a $5m receivables book, of which $3m has been financed and de-recognized. Your balance sheet shows $2m of receivables.
Now imagine you grow by 20%, taking the gross receivables book to $6m, and increase your financing by $1.5m to help fund it. Your reported receivables fall to $1.5m, seemingly generating a $500k ‘inflow’ of working capital, despite the growth.
I hate this. Really hate it.
Because economically, what you've actually got is a $1m investment in receivables, funded by $1.5m of additional financing.
The precise accounting treatment depends on how the agreement transfers risk, rewards and control, with different tests under US GAAP, IFRS and UK GAAP. But regardless of the required GAAP accounting, I think it's SUUUUPER important to keep the business focused on managing working capital before financing.
The financing facility should be a tool for managing liquidity. Not a substitute for working capital discipline. And how you report internally, will make a massive difference in how the business thinks about it.
I cannot stress this enough.
I've seen businesses with receivables financing lose their working capital management muscle. Giving away customer payment terms like candy, failing to manage inventory properly, and generally assuming the credit facility will bail them out, not just in the cashflow, but in the working capital metrics too.
It needs to be the other way around. Manage working capital as efficiently as possible, then use financing to fund what you cannot avoid.
Now, to your actual question about MFCF.
I would separate the working capital movement into two categories:
Core working capital: What is needed to sustain the current level of business, including normal seasonal movements and any structural changes required to maintain earnings. It sounds to me like this might be quite small for you.
Growth working capital: The incremental inventory, receivables, and other net working capital required to support additional business volume.
The first belongs in maintainable free cash flow. The second I would treat as growth capital allocation, just as I would growth capex. And then the funding of that is something different altogether.
So, simplifying the cash flow bridge:
EBITDA
+/- Core working capital movement
- Cash interest, taxes, maintenance capex
= Maintainable Free Cash Flow
- Growth working capital investment
- Growth capex
= Free Cash Flow before financing
+/- Movement in RF debt
= Net cash flow
And importantly, I'd present the financing movements separately in your internal reporting even if your statutory accounting doesn't.
Now, you're right that the distinction between maintenance and growth working capital isn't always obvious.
And in a seasonal business like yours, you need to understand both the annual movement and the peak funding requirement during the year.
TLDR: Don't let a growing factoring facility disguise the underlying cashflow economics.

I’m guessing the Nvidia staff meetings are going to have a much, much different vibe for now, at least.
Every CFO knows the pressure of ‘making the numbers work’ but there must be a real shitshow in Chicago to run through three CFOs in less than 12 months.
From the outside at least, Krishna Rao appears to be doing one hell of a job in there at Anthropic.

If you’re looking to sponsor CFO Secrets Newsletter, fill out this form, and we’ll be in touch.
If you enjoyed today’s content, don’t forget to subscribe.
You can help make sure this newsletter always stays free simply by spreading the word. And when you share CFO Secrets with your finance friends, you’ll earn rewards, including a 50-page PDF guide on what it takes to be a great CFO. Start sharing your unique referral code today: {{rp_refer_url}}
Last weekend’s Playbook offered a guide to building an effective treasury policy.
Last week’s Boardroom Brief laid out how to use receivables financing responsibly… and how to kick the RF habit.


Disclaimer: I am not your accountant, tax advisor, lawyer, CFO, director, or friend. Well, maybe I’m your friend, but I am not any of those other things. Everything I publish represents my opinions only, not advice. Running the finances for a company is serious business, and you should take the proper advice you need




